“Just Take The Flute Out of It, and It Will Be Perfect!”

My Friend, Shayde Christian

In 2009, I was editing images for director friend, Shayde Christian while listening to one of the flute albums — I think that it might have been “The Longing for Good.”

Shayde Christian

Suddenly, after a day of shooting his film, “Painting in the Rain,” he apparently decided to come over to view the images and was peeking around my front door:

“Hey, man…is that your music playing?” Shayde asked.


“Hey, I really like what’s going on there.  Does that mean that you have access to all of the tracks?” he continued.

Not yet knowing where he was going with the line of questioning, I fell into his logic:

“Sure, I do! It’s multi-track software.”

“Hey, if you’d take the flute tracks out of it, it would be perfect!”

It has long since become a running joke between us, but at the time I felt a flush run upwards through my body and with as much humility as I could summon, I informed Shayde that:

“Yes, I could do that, but, you know, I am kind-of known to the people who listen to me as a Native American-style flute player!”

Oh!  I’m sorry!  I just meant that for my movie, I could really use the orchestration part, and not the flute — it doesn’t fit my story!”

“Right,” I mustered.

Three years later, Shayde chose the title track from the album, “Beloved” for a poignant scene in his feature, “Painting in the Rain.”  The flute punctuates the scene perfectly.  He put together the Beloved video as a thank you:

I have enjoyed what I hope is a good joke so much that I have extended it to my Native American flute player friends, including Wolfs Robe, whose traditional albums are almost exclusively played on the Native American flute.

My blood-brother, Wolfs Robe. “Just take the flute out, and it will be perfect!”

Learning to Appreciate the Taiwanese “Ghost Month”

I have several dear friends who hail originally from the island of Taiwan.  I have learned over the years that it is probably a good idea to lie low during Ghost Month.  I used to take this with a grain of cultural salt, but as I age to perfection, I find myself attempting to be more flexible.

Every now and then, when I speak to someone new that I have met from Taiwan, I will ask about Ghost Month.  Immediately, the response is something like,

“How do you know about Ghost Month?  You’d better be careful during that time — a lot of strange things happen!”

  For the benefit of the reader, I quote from Wikipedia:

“Taiwan: Ghost Month

Traditionally, it is believed that ghosts haunt the island of Taiwan for the entire seventh lunar month, when the mid-summer Ghost Festival is held.[5] The month is known as Ghost Month.[6] The first day of the month is marked by opening the gate of a temple, symbolizing the gates of hell. On the twelfth day, lamps on the main altar are lit. On the thirteenth day, a procession of lanterns is held. On the fourteenth day, a parade is held for releasing water lanterns. Incense and food are offered to the spirits to avoid them visiting homes and spirit paper money is also burnt as an offering.[7] During the month, people avoid surgery, buying cars, swimming, and going out after dark. It is also important that addresses are not revealed to the ghosts.”

Burning Ghost Money during Ghost Month (image from Internet)

This year, I did not exactly follow the precepts of Ghost Month.  I traveled to LA, where all appointments that I had arranged were unusually rescheduled out of the month.  And I got a speeding citation in Jerome, AZ for blazing through town at 30 mph at night.  At that moment, I was telling my passengers, who had suffered a motorcycle breakdown that afternoon that it was probably Ghost Month that contributed to the new tire blowing out 20 miles from civilization.  They remarked that they would no longer show any disrespect for Ghost Month.

“In Another World”

I had begun the album, “In Another World” well-before the 7th lunar month this year.  And by the time that I was working on the third song, Ghost Month had begun and suddenly the album took a sharp detour.

The first inkling that I had was during the recording of the song, Redona Me.  The song starts in C minor, a key I don’t usually use, and pulses slowly until the melody begins to soar longingly — hopefully toward an unseen destination.  There is no flute present (I thought of Shayde and smiled to myself).

By the time that I had completed the track, Contessina, I knew something was going to be different.  Then, when I finished the first mix, I sent a copy to Shayde for his input.  True to form, he said something like,

“This is the best s— you have ever done! The album is not just a collection of songs – these are compositions with a theme!”

Not content, he continued,

“I don’t know if this is good advice for you or not, but I like your new stuff so much, that I think you could lose a track or two of those flute solos.”

I asked, “Oh, you mean I should just take some flute out, and it will be perfect?”

“Hey, man,” Shayde quickly responded.  “I know how you feel.  Do you know how many of my own scenes that I have had to cut from my scripts?”

So, I continue to mix — it is yet to be seen whether I’ll be able to heed his advice with grace.  Maybe the ghosts with whom I have tried to make piece will guide the way.

Post Script

In the days following this original post, I received a three-page write up with Shayde’s comments.  Nestled in the thoughts on transitions and old-Bill vs. new-Bill, there was a question about the track, “Redona Me:”

".... "Redone Me.” What is the 6th note in the melody, a 6th? It grabs me by
the heart. And there’s a passing tone around 1:10 that just keeps me so off balance...."

I was more than willing to give him a heart-felt response:

“After an intro of alternating Cminor and Ab major chords, the melody starts its lift on the 5th (G) of the Cminor Chord.  The melody then runs up the the scale of the minor chord passing through the 6th note to the octave, where the chord changes to Ab.  The octave G note, which was the 5th of the Cmin chord then becomes the major 7th of the Ab chord.  So, it would appear that the Ab maj 7 chord is moving you as it almost appears out of nowhere.

The melody then ‘relaxes’ back a full step to the F note as the chord progression reaches for the Bb major chord.  The F note is the 5th in the Bb major chord, thereby strengthening the resolve of the longing in the initial melodic reach by resting at a major triad (F/Bb/D).

At about 1:10, the melody and the chord both rest briefly at Bb again. The melody then raises 1/2 step to the B natural, either implying a G7 chord or a Bb Add B chord that transitions to the Cminor chord again.  This tension is storing the energy to lift to the next melodic vault.

I am sure that answered the question.


, , , ,

  1. Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: